The Bottom Line
Pros
- The performances are uniformly excellent.
- The house band replicates the hits perfectly.
- There's a wide selection of Memphis and Stax classics.
Cons
- Where's Wilson Pickett?
- Purists may balk at the inclusion of Michael McDonald and Chuck D.
Description
- Memphis Soul
- Live
- Various Artists
Guide Review - Soul Comes Home
Most of the Stax artists are alive and performing at or near their peak, which is why the opening notes of Issac Hayes' "Theme From Shaft" still audibly galvanize, and why the jazzy touches Booker T. and the M.G.s put on "Green Onions" make it even more danceable than before. There are also Memphis legends that didn't record for the label (two Al Green classics), and Stax alumni from other cities (Jean Knight's "Mr. Big Stuff").
There are some necessary absences. The great Solomon Burke is an excellent choice to pay tribute to Otis Redding on "Try A Little Tenderness," but there's no telling why ex-Doobie Brother Michael McDonald takes on Otis "Sittin' On The Dock Of The Bay," or why he joins Carla Thomas on "When Something Is Wrong With My Baby." Wilson Pickett is notably absent, his "Mustang Sally" is given the Burke treatment instead. And then there's rapper Chuck D, brought in to give the Bar-Kays' "Soul Finger" a misguided modern relevance it doesn't need; as "Soul Comes Home" proves, this music remains as fresh as tomorrow.





