The Bottom Line
Pros
- This soundtrack is a fitting tribute to the legacy of soul artists, specifically those from Stax.
- Most of the talent here is relatively new, but soulful.
- There's a good flow to the selections, with little to distract.
Cons
- Not everything works, as with most non-score soundtracks.
- It may be impossible to recreate the Stax sound in 2008.
Description
- Release date: November 4, 2008
- Stax 30945
- Studio (1968-2008)
- Single disc
- Original film soundtrack
Guide Review - Various Artists: Soul Men Original Movie Soundtrack
It doesn't hurt that they're performing classic (if rare) soul song, or that the new tracks which make up the bulk of this album were recorded in Memphis with the Bo-Keys (a soul-jazz instrumental outfit looking to carry on the house-band tradition of the MGs). Chris Pierce's rendition of William Bell's 1968 UK smash "Private Number" somehow sounds completely fresh in its classicism, as does Chris Shaw's amazingly Al Green-like take on Sir Mack Rice's "Memphis Train" and Sharon Leal's update of Carla Thomas' 1966 ballad "Comfort Me." The only curve balls are Me'Shell Ndegéocello's country-soul recasting of Steve Cropper's obscure rockabilly "Water" and Sharon Jones and the Dap Kings' bold and shocking rescue of the First Edition's "Just Dropped In (To See What Condition My Condition Was In)."
As for the leads, Mac and Jack do okay, in a Blues Brothers way, by Hayes' "Do Your Thing," James and Bobby Purify's "I'm Your Puppet (helped by John Legend) and Rufus Thomas' "Boogie Ain’t Nuttin’ (But Gettin’ Down)." And even if the opening original "Soul Music" sounds a little too perfect -- a virtual mash-up of "I Can't Turn You Loose" and "Sweet Soul Music" given a workout by Anthony Hamilton -- it's offset by two actual chestnuts: Hayes' faithful remake of "Never Can Say Goodbye," and Eddie Floyd's 1968 hit "I’ve Never Found A Girl (To Love Me Like You Do)."



