1. Home
  2. Entertainment
  3. Oldies Music

Heather Mills vs. Paul McCartney

By , About.com Guide

The case for Heather

  • The revelations about Heather Mills' past (most notoriously, that she engaged in nude modeling in the Eighties) as well as the more controversial claims -- that she was a paid escort and a shoplifter -- have never, true or not, seemed to affect Paul McCartney's feelings. Therefore, it seems not only unfair but legally inadmissible to use her past against her.
  • Her claims of physical abuse by McCartney, if true, would certainly entitle her to a larger portion of his estate than she would normally receive.
  • Mills has also claimed that she offered to sign a pre-nuptial agreement with McCartney, which, if true, would put to rest the "gold digger" label.
  • As the mother of their daughter Beatrice, Heather would naturally be awarded custody of her, yet McCartney has also filed for custody.

    The case for Paul

  • The vast majority of Paul McCartney's fortune was obviously accumulated before meeting Heather in 1999, thus limiting her claim to it. Contrary to reports that Mills could receive half of Paul's fortune, a more realistic percentage would be closer to fifteen percent -- more or less what the ex-Beatle has already offered in a settlement. Mills has refused this offer.
  • There is no recorded or anecdotal evidence of Paul ever being physically abusive towards any woman, which makes her claims of abuse hard to believe.
  • Heather has been accused of embellishing her own personal life story, which could weigh heavy upon her reliability at the trial.
  • Mills can certainly be said to have used her marriage to McCartney in order to further her career, judging by the sharp increase in her public appearances since the trial (in direct contradiction to her stated wish for privacy).

    Resolution

    March 17, 2008: It's over. Heather Mills, ex-model and activist and ex-wife of ex-Beatle Paul McCartney, has been awarded 23.7 million pounds (currently about 47 million dollars) in her divorce from Sir Paul, she announced today. It's a slight victory for Mills, who had asked for much more, but wound up with more than the $32 million Paul had proposed. (Approximately $70,000 a year will be paid in child support for Beatrice, their only daughter, age 4.)

    In a brief statement to reporters, however, Mills revealed that while she will not appeal the decision, she will appeal McCartney's request that the hearing transcripts be made public. This is important because Mills has become a pariah in England, and London especially, for tarnishing the image of the Cute One with her claims of emotional and physical abuse. "I'm so glad it's over," said Mills, "and it was an incredible result, in the end, to secure my and my daughter's future, and that of all the charities that I obviously plan on helping."

    February 15, 2008: Details are a little sketchy, owing to Britain's privacy rules in divorce proceedings, but Court 34 of London's Royal Courts of Justice has been booked through Monday... but only through Monday. Justice Hugh Bennett is expected to take three weeks or so to render a decision even when it's all over, anyway. Meanwhile, boxes and boxes of video tapes, supposedly capturing Mills' "harassment" by the media, have been wheeled into court, where the ex-model has decided to represent herself.

    February 11, 2008: And you thought the trial had already begun. Having been unable to agree on a settlement despite a year and a half of clandestine court hearings, Paul McCartney's divorce settlement with ex-model Heather Mills is expected to be finally decided with these proceedings, off-limits to the public and held in the family division of London's High Court. The proceedings are expected to last five days or so; Mills is expected to take home a final sum somewhere between the 50 million pounds she wants and the 25 million Paul is prepared to offer, or somewhere between $50 and $100 million US dollars.

  • Explore Oldies Music

    About.com Special Features

    Holiday Central

    What to eat, where to go, fun things to do and how to save money on the perfect gifts. More >

    The Best Top 40 Pop Songs

    Is your favorite song on our list? More >

    1. Home
    2. Entertainment
    3. Oldies Music
    4. Oldies History
    5. Oldies Music News
    6. Heather Mills vs. Paul McCartney -- Divorce news and scandal updates>

    ©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

    All rights reserved.